SHARE
FULL MESSAGES ↓
Attaboy

VENUE REVIEW

Attaboy

New York City — Lower East Side

GERALD'S VERDICT

COCKTAILS

9.5/10

ATMOSPHERE

9.2/10

SERVICE

9.0/10

OVERALL

9.3/10

ADDRESS

134 Eldridge St, New York, NY 10002

BEST TIME TO VISIT

Early on a weekday, right at opening. Avoid peak weekend hours to minimize wait times.

MUST ORDER

Penicillin, Boulevardier, or any whisky-forward classic. Trust the bartenders.

PRICE POINT

$$$

Attaboy isn't just a bar; it's an institution, a pilgrimage site for those who truly appreciate the art of the cocktail. Tucked away on the Lower East Side, behind an unassuming door, lies a speakeasy that has mastered the delicate balance of world-class mixology and unpretentious charm. Forget menus; here, the conversation with your bartender is your guide, leading you to a bespoke creation perfectly tailored to your palate. It's an experience that elevates drinking to an art form, a testament to the enduring power of genuine hospitality and exceptional craftsmanship.

THE DRINKS

The true magic of Attaboy lies in its commitment to the craft. While they're renowned for their whisky-forward concoctions like the Penicillin – a smoky, citrusy revelation with Scotch, lemon, ginger, and honey – and the robust Boulevardier, their strength is truly in their ability to improvise. Simply tell your bartender your preferences, and watch as they conjure a drink that feels both familiar and entirely new. Each sip is a journey, a testament to their deep understanding of spirits and flavors. It's a masterclass in mixology, where every drink is a personalized masterpiece.

THE ATMOSPHERE

Stepping into Attaboy is like entering a dimly lit, intimate sanctuary away from the city's relentless pace. The exposed brick, subtle lighting, and classic bar setup create an ambiance that's both sophisticated and incredibly welcoming. It's a place where conversations flow easily, where the clinking of ice and hushed murmurs form a symphony of relaxed enjoyment. Despite its legendary status, Attaboy maintains an approachable vibe, making it the perfect spot for a quiet date, an insightful chat with friends, or a solo evening of contemplative sipping. The atmosphere is as meticulously crafted as the cocktails themselves.

GERALD'S FINAL WORD

"Attaboy isn't just a bar; it's a masterclass in bespoke cocktails and understated cool, a true gem of the Lower East Side."

← BACK TO CITIES